In recent years, there's been a noticeable surge in investment opportunities in Irish whiskey. For those new to this space, yes, that's Irish whiskey spelled with an 'e'—a distinction from Scotch whisky. The Irish have a deep-rooted history with whiskey, dating back to the early seventh century when it is widely believed that whiskey was first created in Ireland. Many are familiar with the globally recognized Irish brand, Jameson, a staple on shelves worldwide.
The late 19th century marked a golden era for the Irish whiskey industry, with 30 distilleries in operation. However, by the 1990s, the landscape had dramatically changed, with only three distilleries remaining. Today, we're witnessing a resurgence, with 42 distilleries now operating across Ireland. This revitalization has sparked interest among investors looking to capitalize on the growing popularity of Irish whiskey.
But this boom in investment opportunities comes with significant concerns. As seasoned whisky investors, we've always approached new opportunities with caution, conducting our own investigations and due diligence to assess their credibility. We've shared our findings with the thousands of members in our social media groups, cautioning them about the potential risks involved.
Brand Matters in Whiskey Investment
The first thing to understand is that while there are many fantastic Irish whiskey brands, such as Jameson, Bushmills, and Redbreast, brand reputation is crucial in whisky investment. Building a reputation in this industry takes years, if not decades, due to the long maturation periods required for whiskey.
With Scotch whisky, we have the advantage of well-established distilleries with proven track records. These distilleries have been producing high-quality whisky for generations, earning consistent reviews and commanding significant prices in the market. This historical data allows us to make informed decisions when selecting Scottish whisky casks for investment.
The Wild West of Irish Whiskey Investment
In contrast, investing in Irish whiskey can feel like navigating the wild west. We've been offered casks of Irish new make whiskey from distilleries that are only a few years old, with little to no proven track record, at prices exceeding €10,000 per cask. This is several times the cost of casks from well-regarded Scottish distilleries with established reputations.
Worse still, these investment companies often lack credible exit strategies. Currently, no independent bottlers appear interested in bottling these products. Given the exorbitant prices, there's no margin for bottlers, making these casks a poor investment choice.
Red Flags in the Market
Our concerns don't end there. Many of the salespeople pushing these overpriced casks seem to have little knowledge of the whiskey industry. In some cases, they can't even pronounce the names of the distilleries correctly—a glaring red flag.
These sellers often cite the recent boom in Irish whiskey sales as a key selling point, highlighting the explosion of new distilleries and the significant increase in global exports. While these numbers are impressive on the surface, a closer look reveals substantial risks.
For instance, sellers may point to the high prices achieved by inaugural bottles from new distilleries at auction, with some fetching over £600. However, these are often isolated incidents. Subsequent bottles from the same distilleries frequently fail to reach anywhere near these prices, or even the reserve price.
This raises a troubling question: Are these bottles being deliberately bid up by those with a vested interest in selling casks from these distilleries, creating a false impression of value?
The Real Investment Value
Consider the average whisky drinker walking into a store. Are they more likely to spend £50 on a proven bottle from a world-renowned distillery, or £600 on a bottle from a brand-new distillery with no established reputation? The answer is clear, and it's a major cause for concern.
These casks are massively overpriced, often four or five times their true market value. The new distilleries in question have yet to produce any whiskies of significant age, and it will take years, if not decades, to determine their true quality. The marketing tactics surrounding these inflated bottle prices should be a massive red flag to any investor.
Our Stance on Irish Whiskey Investment
Given these concerns, we at Cask Capital have made the decision not to offer casks of Irish whiskey from new distilleries. While we wish these distilleries well and hope they will build great reputations over time, we do not believe they represent a credible investment at this time. Our advice is clear: avoid, avoid, avoid.
For those looking to invest in whisky, we recommend focusing on well-established distilleries with proven track records, where the investment potential is more secure and the exit strategies are clear. At Cask Capital, we're committed to offering our clients only the best investment opportunities—those backed by history, reputation, and proven value.
Comments